Home
Osteoporosis Bone Questions Symptoms Questions
Osteoporosis Bone Questions Treatments Questions
Bone Density Questions
Bone Disease Questions
Bone Spurs Questions
Bone Fracture Questions
Osteoporosis General Questions
Osteoporosis Bone Questions
Bone Pain Questions
Site Map
 
 
   
What is the different between back extensors and back flexors which are two osteoporosis exercises?

Question: Back extensors? Back flexors? How do these exercises for the back differ?


Answer:Back extensor: extends (straightens) the back. Exercises include 1) superman: lie down on the floor (on your stomach). Stretch your arms in front of you. Using your back muscles, keeping your arms and legs straight, bend your back. Your hands and feet should raise a little above the floor. Note: with severe Osteoporosis, an alternate version should be done: instead of stretching arms in front, hold them to your side. It may be more comfortable to have your stomach resting on a pillow. Raise your head and chest. 2) : stand, or sit on a chair. Bend your elbows so your arms are at a 90 degree angle. Raise your elbows so your upper arms are straight out (parallel to the floor, and in a straight line with each other). Using your back muscles, try to pinch your shoulder blades together (alternative description: pull your elbows back).

Back flexor: flexes (bends) the back (in this case, bending forwards): Note: according to The Osteoporosis Book, someone with severe Osteoporosis must be careful, to avoid strain and injury. All of these should involve little or no actual movement of the back. 1) Lie down on your back. Bend your knees, so they are at a 90 degree angle (with your feet on the ground). Press your back into the floor. 2) Lie down on your back. Bend your knees so you are comfortable. Lift your head up (pull your chin - mouth closed ;^) - towards your chest).

I have some objections to the technique described for the third exercise, so I am starting with what is in the book and then explaining my objections and alternatives.

3) Lie down on your back. Put your hands under the small of your back (while not stated, I assume that this is to provide support for the back). Raise one foot (leg) at a time, 20 - 40 degrees. Elsewhere in the text it says raise both legs 15 - 20 degrees.

Problem 1: if you only raise one foot at a time, your abdominal muscles are only minimally involved - your back and other leg provide stabilization and your hip flexor will raise the leg (since you are only raising one leg, you can't use your abdominal muscles to lift the leg).

Problem 2: once you've raised your legs beyond something like 10 degrees, you are using your leg flexors to raise the leg. There isn't any more benefit for your abdominal muscles to raise your leg higher.

If someone is out of shape, this may be all they can do. Otherwise, I would recommend something that is a little more strenuous: from the same starting position, press your back into the ground (this should be a minimal movement). Doing this should lift your feet off the ground (my heels raise about 10" off the ground). Note that there are other, more strenuous versions of this exercise, but since they involve more spinal flexion, they may not be safe for someone who has had spinal fractures.


What is Your answer?


 
| Home | Osteoperosis Symptoms Questions | Osteoperosis Treatments Questions | Bone Density Questions | Bone Disease Questions | Bone Spurs Questions | Bone Fracture Questions | Osteoporosis General Questions | Osteoperosis Bone Questions | Bone Pain Questions | Site Map |